swedsl#27 (var-go strategic-fit ADR) closed 2026-07-18 and killed the
Executor/Reviewer path entirely — var-go is gate-only by design, each
consuming repo supplies its own candidate. The real blocker for
enforcement here is swedsl/oath's non-importable module path
(swedsl#35), not a nonexistent Executor. Corrects PROJECT.md,
INCEPTION-OATH.md, and the cd.yml comment to match.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds an oath job to cd.yml: on pull_request, checks out swedsl (the
vargo-gate source — its oath submodule isn't go-installable, module
path isn't a real import path) and runs cmd/vargo-gate against this
repo's linked issue, posting a var-go/oath commit status.
Deliberately NOT required by branch protection: vargo-gate's candidate
is still a hardcoded toy self-test registry (swedsl's own #9 fixture),
not a real PR-diff checker, so it fails closed against any real oath
until swedsl ships an Executor (swedsl#27). Requiring it now would
permanently block every cad-atlas PR. Disclosed in the CI config
comment, PROJECT.md, and docs/INCEPTION-OATH.md (honest-stub
discipline).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Closes the UX sprint's authored layer.
#3 Horizontal-scroll blindness → an always-visible "PIPELINE" overview rail:
9 colour-coded chips (00 Notice → 08 Learn) showing the whole shape at a glance,
each click-to-scroll to its stage. First-timers now see the arc + that more exists.
#4 Real gate glyph — 🔒 on the two checkpoint transitions (human @04, CI @06),
desktop spine + mobile rows.
#5 Reconcile legend with Plain: decorative node pills hidden in Plain, so colour
is reserved for live status (green/amber/coral) — exactly what the legend keys.
(#6 attached chips/grammar: the question-vs-statement label mix is meaningful —
decisions vs milestones — kept; SVG chip background skipped as low-value.)
New Stage.short (guarded by JSON validity via existing tests). build/vet/lint(0)/
test green; desktop Plain screenshot-verified.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-07-20 10:46:08 +02:00
6 changed files with 102 additions and 20 deletions
| S1 | Atlas served at `/`, renders all 9 stages signal→pod | ✅ | `internal/web/handler.go` + `static/cad-atlas.html` |
| S2 | Oath covered in the viz (stages 03 + 06) | ✅ | var-go Oath nodes in the atlas |
| S3 | `var-go/oath` enforces cad-atlas's own PRs | ⏸ **deferred → #1** | var-go v1 candidate is a toy self-test; module not cross-repo consumable. See honesty rule. |
| S3 | `var-go/oath` enforces cad-atlas's own PRs | ⏸ **wired, not enforcing → #8** | `oath` job runs + posts status (#1, verified with a real PR). Not branch-protection-required: candidate is still swedsl's toy self-test, fails closed on every real oath. Blocked on `swedsl/oath` import path (swedsl#35) → cad-atlas writing its own candidate (#8). Not blocked on an Executor — that path was killed by swedsl's ADR-0002. See honesty rule. |
{"no":"STAGE 00","title":"Signals","plain_title":"Notice what's happening","plain":"New ideas and developments worth reacting to are collected — mostly an automated daily/weekly scan of AI news, plus things saved by hand.","path":"→ mathias/signals",
{"no":"STAGE 00","short":"Notice","title":"Signals","plain_title":"Notice what's happening","plain":"New ideas and developments worth reacting to are collected — mostly an automated daily/weekly scan of AI news, plus things saved by hand.","path":"→ mathias/signals",
"trans_label":"Does it matter to us?","trans":"A raw signal only advances if it connects to something we actually care about. Most captured signals stop here; the few that touch the mission get pulled up against a goal.","nodes":[
{"t":"Applied AI Radar","plain_t":"Automated news scan","plain":"An automated scan reads AI news every day (and deeper every week) and keeps only claims backed by a real paper, benchmark, code, or named lab.","d":"Daily Tier-1 + weekly Tier-2 deep pass. Verified-primary bar (paper/benchmark/code/named-lab).","tags":["cron · daily/weekly","→ signals #1–26+"]},
{"t":"Manual capture","plain_t":"Saved by hand","plain":"Anything interesting spotted by hand gets saved into the same inbox.","d":"claude.ai strategic drop · brain capture tool.","tags":["ad-hoc"]},
{"t":"Aspirational surfaces","plain_t":"Not built yet","plain":"Planned but not built yet: sending ideas in by Telegram, voice, or a URL.","pill":"var(--dim)","d":"Telegram / voice / URL → inbox. NOT built.","tags":["gap"]}
]},
{"no":"STAGE 01","cls":"telos","title":"TELOS","plain_title":"Why we're here","plain":"The mission, goals, and problems we're actually trying to solve live here — every piece of work downstream has to trace back to one of these goals.","path":"wiki/telos/",
{"no":"STAGE 01","short":"Why","cls":"telos","title":"TELOS","plain_title":"Why we're here","plain":"The mission, goals, and problems we're actually trying to solve live here — every piece of work downstream has to trace back to one of these goals.","path":"wiki/telos/",
"trans_label":"Worth a session?","trans":"A goal or problem on the board becomes the seed for a design session when it's decided worth working on now. The goal is the input the session must trace back to.","nodes":[
{"t":"Intention substrate","plain_t":"The goal board","plain":"The master list of mission, goals, problems, and current status — the yardstick everything downstream is measured against.","pill":"var(--violet)","d":"Mission · goals · problems · strategies · status. Every downstream item traces to a goal.","tags":["brain_query wing=telos"]}
]},
{"no":"STAGE 02","title":"Strategic session","plain_title":"Think it through","plain":"A human and AI models work out what to do and why, debating hard calls and writing down the decision and what \"done\" will mean.","path":"claude.ai frontier + brain MCP",
{"no":"STAGE 02","short":"Think","title":"Strategic session","plain_title":"Think it through","plain":"A human and AI models work out what to do and why, debating hard calls and writing down the decision and what \"done\" will mean.","path":"claude.ai frontier + brain MCP",
"trans_label":"Decision reached","trans":"It advances only when the thinking converges on a decision and is written down as a concrete, testable specification — not while the answer is still open.","nodes":[
{"t":"Design · ADRs · specs","plain_t":"Decide the approach","plain":"A human and a top-tier AI model figure out the approach and write down the decision plus what a finished result must prove.","d":"Human + frontier model. ISC acceptance criteria written here.","tags":["Define / converge"]},
{"t":"🏛️ LLM Council","plain_t":"AI review panel","plain":"For hard calls, several AI models answer independently, anonymously critique each other, and a \"chair\" model synthesises one verdict — reducing any single model's bias.","cls":"council","pill":"var(--violet)","d":"fan-out → anonymous cross-review → chairman synth. glm-4.7-flash · qwen36-35b · gemma4-31b (chair).","tags":["hard strategic Q","chat.d-ma.be"]},
{"t":"Autoresearch Council","plain_t":"Research review panel","plain":"A parallel version of the same review that vets research findings before they're allowed through.","cls":"council","pill":"var(--violet)","d":"Sibling pipe — ratifies research before the gate.","tags":["proposed: → standalone svc"]}
]},
{"no":"STAGE 03","title":"Spec → Gitea issue","plain_title":"Write the work order","plain":"The decision is turned into a precise, self-contained work order an AI agent can execute unsupervised — with a pass/fail definition of done, a risk rating, and a tamper-proof seal.","path":"agent-ready contract",
{"no":"STAGE 03","short":"Write order","title":"Spec → Gitea issue","plain_title":"Write the work order","plain":"The decision is turned into a precise, self-contained work order an AI agent can execute unsupervised — with a pass/fail definition of done, a risk rating, and a tamper-proof seal.","path":"agent-ready contract",
"trans_label":"Sealed & agent-ready","trans":"Advances to the gate only when the spec is a complete contract: a pass/fail test, a risk tier, a regulatory note, no open human dependencies, one embedded Oath, and a valid cryptographic signature. A malformed or unsigned order fails closed and never reaches the gate.","nodes":[
{"t":"Contract enforced","plain_t":"The work-order rules","plain":"The work order must have a clear pass/fail test, a risk rating, a regulatory-risk note, and no unfinished human dependencies before it counts as agent-ready.","d":"Binary ISC · declared risk tier · reg-risk assessment · no open human deps.","tags":["LOW / MED / HIGH"]},
{"t":"Admission controller","plain_t":"Tamper-proof seal","plain":"The work order is cryptographically signed when created, so any later tampering is detectable and the eventual change can be checked against it.","d":"Ed25519-sign issue body at creation (#36). Verify sig + PR alignment at infra boundary.","tags":["chain of custody"]},
{"t":"⚖️ var-go Oath","plain_t":"Definition of done","plain":"A machine-checkable \"definition of done\" is embedded in the work order — exactly one, or the order is rejected — later used to prove the result actually meets the spec.","cls":"oath","pill":"var(--gold)","d":"Acceptance contract embedded in the issue as a var fenced block. Exactly one — zero/multiple fail closed. Prose → typed steps; failures anchored to byte spans.","tags":["swedsl · var-go","defined here → enforced @06"]}
]},
{"no":"STAGE 04","cls":"gate","title":"Human dispatch gate","plain_title":"Human says go","plain":"A person reviews the work order and its risk and decides whether to release it — the one and only checkpoint where work does not move on its own.","path":"the only checkpoint",
{"no":"STAGE 04","short":"Human go","cls":"gate","title":"Human dispatch gate","plain_title":"Human says go","plain":"A person reviews the work order and its risk and decides whether to release it — the one and only checkpoint where work does not move on its own.","path":"the only checkpoint",
"trans_label":"A human said go","trans":"The hard stop. Nothing crosses automatically — a person must review the plan and risk and explicitly release it, and the repo must be on the allow-list, before any agent starts. This is the single human checkpoint in the whole pipeline.","nodes":[
{"t":"Human triggers execution","plain_t":"The go button","plain":"A person confirms the plan and its risk level, then releases the work — nothing runs until they do.","cls":"gateway","pill":"var(--amber)","d":"Ratify proposed-plan + risk tier, then dispatch.","gate":true},
{"t":"Session-Dispatch bridge","plain_t":"Hand-off to agents","plain":"The approval flips a switch that hands the signed work order over to the agents to start execution.","cls":"bridge","pill":"var(--blue)","d":"claude.ai MCP → gitea:workflow_run_trigger → cad-dispatch.yml → agentsquad. The final design→execution bridge.","tags":["workflow_dispatch"]}
]},
{"no":"STAGE 05","cls":"exec","title":"Execute · agentsquad","plain_title":"Agents do the work","plain":"AI agents actually build the thing — one writes, a second independent one reviews it to avoid marking its own homework — and every step is logged for the audit trail.","path":"koala · cmd/agentsquad-serve",
{"no":"STAGE 05","short":"Build","cls":"exec","title":"Execute · agentsquad","plain_title":"Agents do the work","plain":"AI agents actually build the thing — one writes, a second independent one reviews it to avoid marking its own homework — and every step is logged for the audit trail.","path":"koala · cmd/agentsquad-serve",
"trans_label":"Change proposed","trans":"Advances when the agents finish and open a proposed change (a PR) with its audit log attached. Until there's a concrete change to test, nothing moves.","nodes":[
{"t":"Task API","plain_t":"Start a job","plain":"A request kicks off a job and hands back an id you can poll for progress.","pill":"var(--coral)","d":"POST /tasks → job id · GET /tasks/{id}. taskqueue + serve (v0.12+).","tags":["single agentsquad.yaml"]},
{"t":"Executor + reviewer loop","plain_t":"Build + independent review","plain":"One agent does the work; a second, independent agent on a different model reviews it — so nothing marks its own homework.","cls":"win","pill":"var(--coral)","d":"ADK Go + LiteLLM. Frontier models (local qwen spirals). Reviewer on distinct tier — echo-chamber prevention.","risk":true},
{"t":"dma-cli · routing + scope","plain_t":"Router & guardrails","plain":"A router sends each agent to the right AI backend and enforces what it is and isn't allowed to touch, with a confirmation gate as a guardrail.","cls":"bridge","pill":"var(--blue)","d":"Harness-config arm: routes agents to the right LLM backend. Three-layer scope policy + confirmation gate = CAD guardrail.","tags":["backend routing","scope guardrail"]},
{"t":"assessor-loop ledger","plain_t":"Audit log","plain":"Every step is recorded in a tamper-evident log so the whole run can be audited afterwards.","d":"Attestation ledger (audit trail) + brain session_log on completion.","tags":["audit package"]}
]},
{"no":"STAGE 06","title":"PR → CI","plain_title":"Automatic quality checks","plain":"The proposed change is run through automated tests and safety checks — including a check that it actually satisfies the work order's definition of done — and only a clean pass lets it continue.","path":"Gitea Actions · cd.yml (live)","generate":"ci-jobs",
{"no":"STAGE 06","short":"Check","title":"PR → CI","plain_title":"Automatic quality checks","plain":"The proposed change is run through automated tests and safety checks — including a check that it actually satisfies the work order's definition of done — and only a clean pass lets it continue.","path":"Gitea Actions · cd.yml (live)","generate":"ci-jobs",
"trans_label":"All checks green","trans":"Advances only if every automated check passes — tests, linters, security scan, and the Oath check proving it meets the original work order. Any red gate stops it here; a passing reviewer is not enough to override a failed Oath.","nodes":[
{"t":"Automated checks","plain_t":"Quality checks","plain":"Tests, linters, a security scan, plus a check that the change actually meets the work order — all must pass to continue.","d":"go test · vet · lint · govulncheck + var-go/oath gate.","tags":["green = proceed"]}
]},
{"no":"STAGE 07","cls":"cd","title":"CD → pod","plain_title":"Ship it","plain":"Once everything is green, the change is deployed automatically to the live server — with the rule that merging code alone doesn't ship it; the release has to be pointed at the new version.","path":"Flux GitOps → k3s","generate":"deploy-state",
{"no":"STAGE 07","short":"Ship","cls":"cd","title":"CD → pod","plain_title":"Ship it","plain":"Once everything is green, the change is deployed automatically to the live server — with the rule that merging code alone doesn't ship it; the release has to be pointed at the new version.","path":"Flux GitOps → k3s","generate":"deploy-state",
"trans_label":"It's live","trans":"Once the new version is actually running on the server, the deployed outcome becomes the input to scoring. Advancing means shipped and observable, not just merged.","nodes":[
{"t":"Deploy on green","plain_t":"Auto-deploy when green","plain":"When all checks pass, the release system rolls the new version onto the live server automatically — but only once the release is pointed at that version (merging code alone doesn't ship it).","pill":"var(--green)","d":"Flux reconciles image → k3s pod on koala. Push ≠ deploy: bump tag in mathias/infra.","tags":["ntfy on deploy"]}
]},
{"no":"STAGE 08","cls":"telos","title":"Loop back","plain_title":"Did it work?","plain":"The result is scored against the goal that started it and fed back into the mission board, so the next round of planning learns from what shipped.","path":"→ TELOS (feedback bus)",
{"no":"STAGE 08","short":"Learn","cls":"telos","title":"Loop back","plain_title":"Did it work?","plain":"The result is scored against the goal that started it and fed back into the mission board, so the next round of planning learns from what shipped.","path":"→ TELOS (feedback bus)",
"trans_label":"What did we learn?","trans":"The scored outcome flows back into the mission board so goals, problems, and priorities update — the loop that makes the pipeline a cycle rather than a line. Partly manual today; an explicit improvement target.","nodes":[
{"t":"Close the loop","plain_t":"Score & feed back","plain":"The outcome is scored against the goal that started it and written back to the mission board, so future planning learns from what actually shipped.","pill":"var(--violet)","d":"session_log + attestation → brain. Score deploy outcome vs originating goal. (arc partly manual — improvement target.)","tags":["continuous"]}
Blocking a user prevents them from interacting with repositories, such as opening or commenting on pull requests or issues. Learn more about blocking a user.
mathiasandClaude Sonnet 5