generated from mathias/template-go-web
feat(atlas): UX sprint — progressive disclosure (Plain default + transitions)
Makes the atlas self-explanatory. Every stage/node gains a plain-language layer (plain_title + plain "what happens" + jargon-free node text); the previous technical copy demotes to a subtitle + on-demand detail. A Plain⇄Technical toggle (default Plain, persisted) flips the whole atlas. Biggest win: every transition arrow is now LABELLED with "what must be true to advance" (the gated- flow story that was invisible), gate hops (human @04, CI @06) styled distinctly. Spine repositioned into a uniform header band so labels never collide with copy. Copy grounded in a fresh-eyes UX review (docs/UX-REVIEW.md, reviewer≠implementer). Data model: plain_title/plain/trans_label/trans on Stage, plain on Node — guarded by a test (every stage has plain_title + a transition). Live overlays unchanged. Verified: build/vet/lint(0)/test green; Plain render screenshot-checked. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Claude Opus 4.8
@@ -0,0 +1,215 @@
|
||||
# CAD Atlas — Fresh-Eyes UX Review
|
||||
|
||||
Reviewer role: fresh-eyes UX (not implementer). This document critiques the copy and
|
||||
information architecture of the "From Signal to Pod" atlas and specifies the
|
||||
progressive-disclosure layer for the coming sprint. It does not change code.
|
||||
|
||||
Sources reviewed:
|
||||
- `internal/atlas/atlas.json` (authored stages + nodes)
|
||||
- `internal/web/handler.go` (which stages get live data overlaid)
|
||||
- `.context/PROJECT.md` (ground-truth meaning of each stage/gate)
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
## 1. Diagnosis — why the current atlas is hard for a naive viewer
|
||||
|
||||
The atlas is written by the person who built the pipeline, for the person who built the
|
||||
pipeline. Almost every node names a **mechanism** (`Ed25519 admission controller`,
|
||||
`var-go Oath`, `dma-cli`, `assessor-loop ledger`, `agentsquad`, `ISC`, `TELOS`) rather
|
||||
than the **thing that happens to a piece of work**. A compliance officer or a new
|
||||
engineer cannot answer the two questions they actually have: *"what is happening to the
|
||||
work at this step?"* and *"why does it move to the next step?"*
|
||||
|
||||
The second question is completely unanswered. The atlas renders nine stages connected by
|
||||
arrows, but the arrows carry **zero copy**. There is no statement of what has to be true
|
||||
for work to advance — which is exactly where the interesting governance lives (a human
|
||||
sign-off at 04, a green CI gate at 06, an integrity check at 03). The pipeline's whole
|
||||
selling point is "auditable, gated flow," yet the gates between stages are invisible.
|
||||
A viewer sees a row of jargon boxes and an implied left-to-right drift, with no sense of
|
||||
what earns each hop.
|
||||
|
||||
Two smaller aggravators: (a) the reel is dense — 20+ nodes, colour-coded pills whose
|
||||
meaning is never keyed, and Swedish-homelab proper nouns (koala, iguana, flamingo) that a
|
||||
stakeholder can't decode; (b) Stage 06 is authored-empty (it's generated live from CI),
|
||||
so on a cold/offline load that column can read as "nothing happens here," which is the
|
||||
opposite of the truth — CI is a governance gate.
|
||||
|
||||
The fix is not to dumb it down. It is to make **plain-language the default layer** — a
|
||||
one-line "what happens + why" per stage, and a labelled "what must be true to advance"
|
||||
per arrow — and demote today's precise, correct technical copy to an **on-demand layer**.
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
## 2. Per-stage plain-language map (00–08)
|
||||
|
||||
| stage | plain_title | plain_what (one jargon-free sentence) | keep_technical (on-demand) |
|
||||
|---|---|---|---|
|
||||
| **00 Signals** | Notice what's happening | New ideas and developments worth reacting to are collected — mostly an automated daily/weekly scan of AI news, plus things saved by hand. | "Signals → mathias/signals"; Applied AI Radar (Tier-1 daily / Tier-2 weekly), verified-primary bar; brain capture; aspirational inbox surfaces (not built). |
|
||||
| **01 TELOS** | Why we're here | The mission, goals, and problems we're actually trying to solve live here — every piece of work downstream has to trace back to one of these goals. | "TELOS — intention substrate", `wiki/telos/`, `brain_query wing=telos`. |
|
||||
| **02 Strategic session** | Think it through | A human and AI models work out *what* to do and *why*, debating hard calls and writing down the decision and what "done" will mean. | "Strategic session" — claude.ai frontier + brain MCP; ADRs/specs; ISC acceptance criteria; LLM Council (fan-out → anonymous cross-review → chairman synth); Autoresearch Council. |
|
||||
| **03 Spec → Gitea issue** | Write the work order | The decision is turned into a precise, self-contained work order that an AI agent can execute unsupervised — with a pass/fail definition of done, a risk rating, and a tamper-proof seal. | "Spec → Gitea issue" — binary ISC, risk tier LOW/MED/HIGH, reg-risk assessment, no open human deps; Ed25519 admission controller (#36); var-go Oath (single fenced block, fail-closed). |
|
||||
| **04 Human dispatch gate** | Human says go | A person reviews the work order and its risk and decides whether to release it — this is the one and only checkpoint where work does not move on its own. | "Human dispatch gate — the only checkpoint"; ratify plan + risk tier; Session-Dispatch bridge (claude.ai MCP → `workflow_run_trigger` → `cad-dispatch.yml` → agentsquad); dispatch-allow eligibility. |
|
||||
| **05 Execute · agentsquad** | Agents do the work | AI agents actually build the thing — one writes, a second independent one reviews it to avoid marking its own homework — and every step is logged for the audit trail. | "Execute · agentsquad" on koala; Task API (`POST /tasks`); executor+reviewer loop (ADK Go + LiteLLM, reviewer on distinct tier); dma-cli routing + 3-layer scope guardrail; assessor-loop attestation ledger + brain session_log. |
|
||||
| **06 PR → CI** | Automatic quality checks | The proposed change is run through automated tests and safety checks — including a check that it actually satisfies the work order's definition of done — and only a clean pass lets it continue. | "PR → CI" — Gitea Actions `cd.yml`; go test/vet/lint/govulncheck; **var-go/oath gate** (correctness floor over the reviewer, anti-rubber-stamp #55). *Nodes generated live from the latest CI run.* |
|
||||
| **07 CD → pod** | Ship it | Once everything is green, the change is deployed automatically to the live server — with the rule that merging code alone doesn't ship it; the release has to be pointed at the new version. | "CD → pod" — Flux GitOps → k3s on koala; "push ≠ deploy: bump tag in mathias/infra"; ntfy on deploy. *Deploy + Flux state overlaid live.* |
|
||||
| **08 Loop back** | Did it work? | The result is scored against the goal that started it and fed back into the mission board, so the next round of planning learns from what shipped. | "Loop back → TELOS (feedback bus)"; session_log + attestation → brain; outcome scored vs originating goal; arc partly manual (improvement target). |
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
## 3. Per-node plain restatements
|
||||
|
||||
The existing `d` text stays as the **technical detail layer**. Each `plain` line below is
|
||||
the jargon-free default. Kept accurate to PROJECT.md.
|
||||
|
||||
**Stage 00 — Signals**
|
||||
- *Applied AI Radar* → **"An automated scan reads AI news every day (and deeper every week) and keeps only claims backed by a real paper, benchmark, code, or named lab."**
|
||||
- *Manual capture* → **"Anything interesting spotted by hand gets saved into the same inbox."**
|
||||
- *Aspirational surfaces* → **"Planned-but-not-built: sending ideas in by Telegram, voice, or a URL."** (mark clearly as a gap / not yet real.)
|
||||
|
||||
**Stage 01 — TELOS**
|
||||
- *Intention substrate* → **"The master list of mission, goals, problems, and current status — the yardstick everything downstream is measured against."**
|
||||
|
||||
**Stage 02 — Strategic session**
|
||||
- *Design · ADRs · specs* → **"A human and a top-tier AI model figure out the approach and write down the decision plus what a finished result must prove."**
|
||||
- *LLM Council* → **"For hard calls, several AI models answer independently, anonymously critique each other, and a 'chair' model synthesises one verdict — reduces any single model's bias."**
|
||||
- *Autoresearch Council* → **"A parallel version of the same review that vets research findings before they're allowed through."**
|
||||
|
||||
**Stage 03 — Spec → Gitea issue**
|
||||
- *Contract enforced* → **"The work order must have a clear pass/fail test, a risk rating, a regulatory-risk note, and no unfinished human dependencies before it counts as agent-ready."**
|
||||
- *Admission controller* → **"The work order is cryptographically signed when created, so any later tampering is detectable and the eventual change can be checked against it."**
|
||||
- *var-go Oath* → **"A machine-checkable 'definition of done' is embedded in the work order — exactly one, or the order is rejected — later used to prove the result actually meets the spec."**
|
||||
|
||||
**Stage 04 — Human dispatch gate**
|
||||
- *Human triggers execution* → **"A person confirms the plan and its risk level, then releases the work — nothing runs until they do."**
|
||||
- *Session-Dispatch bridge* → **"The approval flips a switch that hands the signed work order over to the agents to start execution."**
|
||||
|
||||
**Stage 05 — Execute · agentsquad**
|
||||
- *Task API* → **"A request kicks off a job and hands back an id you can poll for progress."**
|
||||
- *Executor + reviewer loop* → **"One agent does the work; a second, independent agent on a different model reviews it — so nothing marks its own homework."**
|
||||
- *dma-cli · routing + scope* → **"A router sends each agent to the right AI backend and enforces what it is and isn't allowed to touch, with a confirmation gate as a guardrail."**
|
||||
- *assessor-loop ledger* → **"Every step is recorded in a tamper-evident log so the whole run can be audited afterwards."**
|
||||
|
||||
**Stage 06 — PR → CI** *(nodes generated live from the latest CI run — no authored nodes)*
|
||||
- Live jobs render here; the plain framing for the column is: **"Automated tests and safety checks run on the proposed change, including a check that it truly satisfies the work order — only a clean pass moves on."**
|
||||
|
||||
**Stage 07 — CD → pod**
|
||||
- *Deploy on green* → **"When all checks pass, the release system rolls the new version onto the live server automatically — but only once the release is pointed at that version (merging code alone doesn't ship it)."** *(live deploy + Flux status also shown.)*
|
||||
|
||||
**Stage 08 — Loop back**
|
||||
- *Close the loop* → **"The outcome is scored against the goal that started it and written back to the mission board, so future planning learns from what actually shipped."**
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
## 4. Transitions — the key deliverable
|
||||
|
||||
For each arrow: *what moves the work forward, and what must be true for it to advance.*
|
||||
These should be rendered **on the arrows themselves** (see §5). Today they are blank.
|
||||
|
||||
- **00 → 01 — "Does it matter to us?"**
|
||||
A raw signal only advances if it connects to something we actually care about. Most
|
||||
captured signals stop here; the few that touch the mission get pulled up against a goal.
|
||||
|
||||
- **01 → 02 — "Worth a session?"**
|
||||
A goal or problem on the board becomes the seed for a design session when it's decided
|
||||
it's worth working on now. The goal is the input the session must trace back to.
|
||||
|
||||
- **02 → 03 — "Decision reached."**
|
||||
Once the debate converges on a decision (and what "done" will mean), it advances only
|
||||
when that thinking is written down as a concrete, testable specification — not while
|
||||
the answer is still open.
|
||||
|
||||
- **03 → 04 — "Order written, sealed, agent-ready."**
|
||||
Work advances to the gate only when the spec is a complete contract: a pass/fail test, a
|
||||
risk tier, a regulatory note, no open human dependencies, one embedded Oath, and a valid
|
||||
cryptographic signature. A malformed or unsigned order fails closed and does not reach
|
||||
the gate.
|
||||
|
||||
- **04 → 05 — "A human said go."**
|
||||
This is the hard stop. Nothing crosses automatically. A person must review the plan and
|
||||
risk and explicitly release it, and the repo must be on the allow-list, before any agent
|
||||
starts. This is the single human checkpoint in the whole pipeline.
|
||||
|
||||
- **05 → 06 — "Agents produced a change."**
|
||||
Work advances when the agents finish and open a proposed change (a PR) with its audit
|
||||
log attached. Until there's a concrete change to test, nothing moves.
|
||||
|
||||
- **06 → 07 — "All checks green."**
|
||||
The change advances only if every automated check passes — tests, linters, security
|
||||
scan, **and** the Oath check proving it meets the original work order. Any red gate stops
|
||||
it here; a passing reviewer is not enough to override a failed Oath.
|
||||
|
||||
- **07 → 08 — "It's live."**
|
||||
Once the new version is actually running on the server, the deployed outcome becomes the
|
||||
input to scoring. Advancing means "shipped and observable," not just "merged."
|
||||
|
||||
- **08 → TELOS (feedback bus, dashed) — "What did we learn?"**
|
||||
The scored outcome flows back into the mission board so goals, problems, and priorities
|
||||
update. This is the loop that makes the pipeline a cycle rather than a line. Note per
|
||||
PROJECT.md this arc is **partly manual today** and is an explicit improvement target —
|
||||
the dashed styling should read as "aspirational / not fully automated," not just decorative.
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
## 5. Progressive-disclosure recommendations
|
||||
|
||||
**Default (Plain) layer — what everyone sees on load:**
|
||||
- Each stage column shows: the **plain_title** as the headline, the technical title as a
|
||||
smaller subtitle, and the one-line **plain_what** directly under it.
|
||||
- Each node shows its **plain** one-liner as the primary text. The current `d` string is
|
||||
hidden by default.
|
||||
- Each arrow shows a short **transition label** (the bolded phrase from §4, e.g. "A human
|
||||
said go", "All checks green") — this is the single biggest comprehension win and must
|
||||
ship in the default layer, not behind a toggle.
|
||||
|
||||
**On hover / expand (per node):**
|
||||
- Reveal the technical `d` text, the `tags`, and the pill's meaning.
|
||||
- On the arrow, hovering expands the short label into the full "what must be true to
|
||||
advance" sentence from §4.
|
||||
|
||||
**Plain ⇄ Technical toggle (global):**
|
||||
- A single top-level switch, defaulting to **Plain**. Persist the choice (localStorage).
|
||||
- Plain: plain_title headline, plain_what, plain node lines, short arrow labels. Proper
|
||||
nouns (koala/iguana/agentsquad/TELOS) suppressed or shown only as a footnote.
|
||||
- Technical: today's exact copy — titles, `d` strings, tags, substrate host specs — i.e.
|
||||
the atlas as it exists now. Nothing is lost; the current view becomes "Technical."
|
||||
- The toggle should crossfade in place, not reflow the whole layout, so a viewer can flip
|
||||
back and forth and map plain↔technical on the same node.
|
||||
|
||||
**Visual cues for the currently-bare transitions:**
|
||||
- Give every arrow a **label chip** sitting on the spine. Gate arrows (04→05 human, 06→07
|
||||
CI) get a distinct treatment — a lock/shield glyph and a stronger colour — because those
|
||||
are the governance moments the whole atlas exists to show.
|
||||
- Make the **08 → TELOS feedback bus** visibly different (dashed + "partly manual" tag) so
|
||||
its aspirational status is honest, matching PROJECT.md's dogfooding-honesty discipline.
|
||||
- Add a small, always-visible **legend** keying the pill colours and the three gate types
|
||||
(integrity / eligibility / correctness), since colour is currently unexplained.
|
||||
- For **Stage 06** (authored-empty, generated live): when no live CI data is present, show
|
||||
the plain_what placeholder ("Automated tests and safety checks run…") rather than an
|
||||
empty column, so it never reads as "nothing happens here."
|
||||
|
||||
**Three-gate overlay (stretch, high value for the compliance audience):**
|
||||
- A "show governance gates" toggle that highlights the three orthogonal gates on top of
|
||||
the pipeline: integrity (03, Ed25519), eligibility (04/05, dispatch-allow), correctness
|
||||
(06, Oath). This directly serves the "audit chain is the viz data" thesis for a
|
||||
compliance/exec viewer.
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
## 6. Prioritized punch list (top 8 by comprehension impact)
|
||||
|
||||
1. **Label every arrow with a plain "what must be true to advance" phrase** (§4). Biggest
|
||||
miss, biggest win — turns a row of boxes into a story of gated flow. Default layer.
|
||||
2. **Add a plain_what one-liner per stage** as the default column copy (§2), with the
|
||||
technical title demoted to subtitle.
|
||||
3. **Ship the Plain ⇄ Technical global toggle, defaulting to Plain**, persisting choice;
|
||||
current copy becomes the Technical view (nothing thrown away).
|
||||
4. **Rewrite node primary text to the plain lines** (§3); move existing `d` to hover/expand.
|
||||
5. **Visually distinguish the two real gates (04 human, 06 CI)** with lock/shield glyphs and
|
||||
stronger colour so the checkpoints read as checkpoints.
|
||||
6. **Add a legend** keying pill colours and the three gate types — colour currently carries
|
||||
meaning nobody can decode.
|
||||
7. **Fix the Stage-06 empty-column problem**: show a plain placeholder when live CI data is
|
||||
absent, so the CI gate never looks like a no-op.
|
||||
8. **Make the 08→TELOS feedback bus honestly aspirational** (dashed + "partly manual" tag),
|
||||
and suppress homelab proper nouns (koala/iguana/flamingo/agentsquad/TELOS) in Plain mode,
|
||||
surfacing them only in Technical or a footnote.
|
||||
+36
-27
@@ -7,40 +7,49 @@
|
||||
],
|
||||
"ns": "Tailscale mesh · ns: ai-stack · supervisor(→brain) · gitea-mcp · infra-mcp · council",
|
||||
"stages": [
|
||||
{"no":"STAGE 00","title":"Signals","path":"→ mathias/signals","nodes":[
|
||||
{"t":"Applied AI Radar","d":"Daily Tier-1 + weekly Tier-2 deep pass. Verified-primary bar (paper/benchmark/code/named-lab).","tags":["cron · daily/weekly","→ signals #1–26+"]},
|
||||
{"t":"Manual capture","d":"claude.ai strategic drop · brain capture tool.","tags":["ad-hoc"]},
|
||||
{"t":"Aspirational surfaces","pill":"var(--dim)","d":"Telegram / voice / URL → inbox. NOT built.","tags":["gap"]}
|
||||
{"no":"STAGE 00","title":"Signals","plain_title":"Notice what's happening","plain":"New ideas and developments worth reacting to are collected — mostly an automated daily/weekly scan of AI news, plus things saved by hand.","path":"→ mathias/signals",
|
||||
"trans_label":"Does it matter to us?","trans":"A raw signal only advances if it connects to something we actually care about. Most captured signals stop here; the few that touch the mission get pulled up against a goal.","nodes":[
|
||||
{"t":"Applied AI Radar","plain":"An automated scan reads AI news every day (and deeper every week) and keeps only claims backed by a real paper, benchmark, code, or named lab.","d":"Daily Tier-1 + weekly Tier-2 deep pass. Verified-primary bar (paper/benchmark/code/named-lab).","tags":["cron · daily/weekly","→ signals #1–26+"]},
|
||||
{"t":"Manual capture","plain":"Anything interesting spotted by hand gets saved into the same inbox.","d":"claude.ai strategic drop · brain capture tool.","tags":["ad-hoc"]},
|
||||
{"t":"Aspirational surfaces","plain":"Planned but not built yet: sending ideas in by Telegram, voice, or a URL.","pill":"var(--dim)","d":"Telegram / voice / URL → inbox. NOT built.","tags":["gap"]}
|
||||
]},
|
||||
{"no":"STAGE 01","cls":"telos","title":"TELOS","path":"wiki/telos/","nodes":[
|
||||
{"t":"Intention substrate","pill":"var(--violet)","d":"Mission · goals · problems · strategies · status. Every downstream item traces to a goal.","tags":["brain_query wing=telos"]}
|
||||
{"no":"STAGE 01","cls":"telos","title":"TELOS","plain_title":"Why we're here","plain":"The mission, goals, and problems we're actually trying to solve live here — every piece of work downstream has to trace back to one of these goals.","path":"wiki/telos/",
|
||||
"trans_label":"Worth a session?","trans":"A goal or problem on the board becomes the seed for a design session when it's decided worth working on now. The goal is the input the session must trace back to.","nodes":[
|
||||
{"t":"Intention substrate","plain":"The master list of mission, goals, problems, and current status — the yardstick everything downstream is measured against.","pill":"var(--violet)","d":"Mission · goals · problems · strategies · status. Every downstream item traces to a goal.","tags":["brain_query wing=telos"]}
|
||||
]},
|
||||
{"no":"STAGE 02","title":"Strategic session","path":"claude.ai frontier + brain MCP","nodes":[
|
||||
{"t":"Design · ADRs · specs","d":"Human + frontier model. ISC acceptance criteria written here.","tags":["Define / converge"]},
|
||||
{"t":"🏛️ LLM Council","cls":"council","pill":"var(--violet)","d":"fan-out → anonymous cross-review → chairman synth. glm-4.7-flash · qwen36-35b · gemma4-31b (chair).","tags":["hard strategic Q","chat.d-ma.be"]},
|
||||
{"t":"Autoresearch Council","cls":"council","pill":"var(--violet)","d":"Sibling pipe — ratifies research before the gate.","tags":["proposed: → standalone svc"]}
|
||||
{"no":"STAGE 02","title":"Strategic session","plain_title":"Think it through","plain":"A human and AI models work out what to do and why, debating hard calls and writing down the decision and what \"done\" will mean.","path":"claude.ai frontier + brain MCP",
|
||||
"trans_label":"Decision reached","trans":"It advances only when the thinking converges on a decision and is written down as a concrete, testable specification — not while the answer is still open.","nodes":[
|
||||
{"t":"Design · ADRs · specs","plain":"A human and a top-tier AI model figure out the approach and write down the decision plus what a finished result must prove.","d":"Human + frontier model. ISC acceptance criteria written here.","tags":["Define / converge"]},
|
||||
{"t":"🏛️ LLM Council","plain":"For hard calls, several AI models answer independently, anonymously critique each other, and a \"chair\" model synthesises one verdict — reducing any single model's bias.","cls":"council","pill":"var(--violet)","d":"fan-out → anonymous cross-review → chairman synth. glm-4.7-flash · qwen36-35b · gemma4-31b (chair).","tags":["hard strategic Q","chat.d-ma.be"]},
|
||||
{"t":"Autoresearch Council","plain":"A parallel version of the same review that vets research findings before they're allowed through.","cls":"council","pill":"var(--violet)","d":"Sibling pipe — ratifies research before the gate.","tags":["proposed: → standalone svc"]}
|
||||
]},
|
||||
{"no":"STAGE 03","title":"Spec → Gitea issue","path":"agent-ready contract","nodes":[
|
||||
{"t":"Contract enforced","d":"Binary ISC · declared risk tier · reg-risk assessment · no open human deps.","tags":["LOW / MED / HIGH"]},
|
||||
{"t":"Admission controller","d":"Ed25519-sign issue body at creation (#36). Verify sig + PR alignment at infra boundary.","tags":["chain of custody"]},
|
||||
{"t":"⚖️ var-go Oath","cls":"oath","pill":"var(--gold)","d":"Acceptance contract embedded in the issue as a var fenced block. Exactly one — zero/multiple fail closed. Prose → typed steps; failures anchored to byte spans.","tags":["swedsl · var-go","defined here → enforced @06"]}
|
||||
{"no":"STAGE 03","title":"Spec → Gitea issue","plain_title":"Write the work order","plain":"The decision is turned into a precise, self-contained work order an AI agent can execute unsupervised — with a pass/fail definition of done, a risk rating, and a tamper-proof seal.","path":"agent-ready contract",
|
||||
"trans_label":"Order written, sealed, agent-ready","trans":"Advances to the gate only when the spec is a complete contract: a pass/fail test, a risk tier, a regulatory note, no open human dependencies, one embedded Oath, and a valid cryptographic signature. A malformed or unsigned order fails closed and never reaches the gate.","nodes":[
|
||||
{"t":"Contract enforced","plain":"The work order must have a clear pass/fail test, a risk rating, a regulatory-risk note, and no unfinished human dependencies before it counts as agent-ready.","d":"Binary ISC · declared risk tier · reg-risk assessment · no open human deps.","tags":["LOW / MED / HIGH"]},
|
||||
{"t":"Admission controller","plain":"The work order is cryptographically signed when created, so any later tampering is detectable and the eventual change can be checked against it.","d":"Ed25519-sign issue body at creation (#36). Verify sig + PR alignment at infra boundary.","tags":["chain of custody"]},
|
||||
{"t":"⚖️ var-go Oath","plain":"A machine-checkable \"definition of done\" is embedded in the work order — exactly one, or the order is rejected — later used to prove the result actually meets the spec.","cls":"oath","pill":"var(--gold)","d":"Acceptance contract embedded in the issue as a var fenced block. Exactly one — zero/multiple fail closed. Prose → typed steps; failures anchored to byte spans.","tags":["swedsl · var-go","defined here → enforced @06"]}
|
||||
]},
|
||||
{"no":"STAGE 04","cls":"gate","title":"Human dispatch gate","path":"the only checkpoint","nodes":[
|
||||
{"t":"Human triggers execution","cls":"gateway","pill":"var(--amber)","d":"Ratify proposed-plan + risk tier, then dispatch.","gate":true},
|
||||
{"t":"Session-Dispatch bridge","cls":"bridge","pill":"var(--blue)","d":"claude.ai MCP → gitea:workflow_run_trigger → cad-dispatch.yml → agentsquad. The final design→execution bridge.","tags":["workflow_dispatch"]}
|
||||
{"no":"STAGE 04","cls":"gate","title":"Human dispatch gate","plain_title":"Human says go","plain":"A person reviews the work order and its risk and decides whether to release it — the one and only checkpoint where work does not move on its own.","path":"the only checkpoint",
|
||||
"trans_label":"A human said go","trans":"The hard stop. Nothing crosses automatically — a person must review the plan and risk and explicitly release it, and the repo must be on the allow-list, before any agent starts. This is the single human checkpoint in the whole pipeline.","nodes":[
|
||||
{"t":"Human triggers execution","plain":"A person confirms the plan and its risk level, then releases the work — nothing runs until they do.","cls":"gateway","pill":"var(--amber)","d":"Ratify proposed-plan + risk tier, then dispatch.","gate":true},
|
||||
{"t":"Session-Dispatch bridge","plain":"The approval flips a switch that hands the signed work order over to the agents to start execution.","cls":"bridge","pill":"var(--blue)","d":"claude.ai MCP → gitea:workflow_run_trigger → cad-dispatch.yml → agentsquad. The final design→execution bridge.","tags":["workflow_dispatch"]}
|
||||
]},
|
||||
{"no":"STAGE 05","cls":"exec","title":"Execute · agentsquad","path":"koala · cmd/agentsquad-serve","nodes":[
|
||||
{"t":"Task API","pill":"var(--coral)","d":"POST /tasks → job id · GET /tasks/{id}. taskqueue + serve (v0.12+).","tags":["single agentsquad.yaml"]},
|
||||
{"t":"Executor + reviewer loop","cls":"win","pill":"var(--coral)","d":"ADK Go + LiteLLM. Frontier models (local qwen spirals). Reviewer on distinct tier — echo-chamber prevention.","risk":true},
|
||||
{"t":"dma-cli · routing + scope","cls":"bridge","pill":"var(--blue)","d":"Harness-config arm: routes agents to the right LLM backend. Three-layer scope policy + confirmation gate = CAD guardrail.","tags":["backend routing","scope guardrail"]},
|
||||
{"t":"assessor-loop ledger","d":"Attestation ledger (audit trail) + brain session_log on completion.","tags":["audit package"]}
|
||||
{"no":"STAGE 05","cls":"exec","title":"Execute · agentsquad","plain_title":"Agents do the work","plain":"AI agents actually build the thing — one writes, a second independent one reviews it to avoid marking its own homework — and every step is logged for the audit trail.","path":"koala · cmd/agentsquad-serve",
|
||||
"trans_label":"Agents produced a change","trans":"Advances when the agents finish and open a proposed change (a PR) with its audit log attached. Until there's a concrete change to test, nothing moves.","nodes":[
|
||||
{"t":"Task API","plain":"A request kicks off a job and hands back an id you can poll for progress.","pill":"var(--coral)","d":"POST /tasks → job id · GET /tasks/{id}. taskqueue + serve (v0.12+).","tags":["single agentsquad.yaml"]},
|
||||
{"t":"Executor + reviewer loop","plain":"One agent does the work; a second, independent agent on a different model reviews it — so nothing marks its own homework.","cls":"win","pill":"var(--coral)","d":"ADK Go + LiteLLM. Frontier models (local qwen spirals). Reviewer on distinct tier — echo-chamber prevention.","risk":true},
|
||||
{"t":"dma-cli · routing + scope","plain":"A router sends each agent to the right AI backend and enforces what it is and isn't allowed to touch, with a confirmation gate as a guardrail.","cls":"bridge","pill":"var(--blue)","d":"Harness-config arm: routes agents to the right LLM backend. Three-layer scope policy + confirmation gate = CAD guardrail.","tags":["backend routing","scope guardrail"]},
|
||||
{"t":"assessor-loop ledger","plain":"Every step is recorded in a tamper-evident log so the whole run can be audited afterwards.","d":"Attestation ledger (audit trail) + brain session_log on completion.","tags":["audit package"]}
|
||||
]},
|
||||
{"no":"STAGE 06","title":"PR → CI","path":"Gitea Actions · cd.yml (live)","generate":"ci-jobs","nodes":[]},
|
||||
{"no":"STAGE 07","cls":"cd","title":"CD → pod","path":"Flux GitOps → k3s","generate":"deploy-state","nodes":[
|
||||
{"t":"Deploy on green","pill":"var(--green)","d":"Flux reconciles image → k3s pod on koala. Push ≠ deploy: bump tag in mathias/infra.","tags":["ntfy on deploy"]}
|
||||
{"no":"STAGE 06","title":"PR → CI","plain_title":"Automatic quality checks","plain":"The proposed change is run through automated tests and safety checks — including a check that it actually satisfies the work order's definition of done — and only a clean pass lets it continue.","path":"Gitea Actions · cd.yml (live)","generate":"ci-jobs",
|
||||
"trans_label":"All checks green","trans":"Advances only if every automated check passes — tests, linters, security scan, and the Oath check proving it meets the original work order. Any red gate stops it here; a passing reviewer is not enough to override a failed Oath.","nodes":[]},
|
||||
{"no":"STAGE 07","cls":"cd","title":"CD → pod","plain_title":"Ship it","plain":"Once everything is green, the change is deployed automatically to the live server — with the rule that merging code alone doesn't ship it; the release has to be pointed at the new version.","path":"Flux GitOps → k3s","generate":"deploy-state",
|
||||
"trans_label":"It's live","trans":"Once the new version is actually running on the server, the deployed outcome becomes the input to scoring. Advancing means shipped and observable, not just merged.","nodes":[
|
||||
{"t":"Deploy on green","plain":"When all checks pass, the release system rolls the new version onto the live server automatically — but only once the release is pointed at that version (merging code alone doesn't ship it).","pill":"var(--green)","d":"Flux reconciles image → k3s pod on koala. Push ≠ deploy: bump tag in mathias/infra.","tags":["ntfy on deploy"]}
|
||||
]},
|
||||
{"no":"STAGE 08","cls":"telos","title":"Loop back","path":"→ TELOS (feedback bus)","nodes":[
|
||||
{"t":"Close the loop","pill":"var(--violet)","d":"session_log + attestation → brain. Score deploy outcome vs originating goal. (arc partly manual — improvement target.)","tags":["continuous"]}
|
||||
{"no":"STAGE 08","cls":"telos","title":"Loop back","plain_title":"Did it work?","plain":"The result is scored against the goal that started it and fed back into the mission board, so the next round of planning learns from what shipped.","path":"→ TELOS (feedback bus)",
|
||||
"trans_label":"What did we learn?","trans":"The scored outcome flows back into the mission board so goals, problems, and priorities update — the loop that makes the pipeline a cycle rather than a line. Partly manual today; an explicit improvement target.","nodes":[
|
||||
{"t":"Close the loop","plain":"The outcome is scored against the goal that started it and written back to the mission board, so future planning learns from what actually shipped.","pill":"var(--violet)","d":"session_log + attestation → brain. Score deploy outcome vs originating goal. (arc partly manual — improvement target.)","tags":["continuous"]}
|
||||
]}
|
||||
]
|
||||
}
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -41,6 +41,29 @@ func TestBuild_OverlaysCIStageNodesFromWorkflow(t *testing.T) {
|
||||
}
|
||||
}
|
||||
|
||||
func TestDefault_HasPlainLayerAndTransitions(t *testing.T) {
|
||||
a, err := atlas.Build(atlas.DataJSON, []byte("jobs:\n guard:\n a: 1\n"))
|
||||
if err != nil {
|
||||
t.Fatalf("Build embedded atlas: %v", err)
|
||||
}
|
||||
for _, s := range a.Stages {
|
||||
if s.PlainTitle == "" {
|
||||
t.Fatalf("stage %s missing plain_title", s.No)
|
||||
}
|
||||
if s.TransLabel == "" {
|
||||
t.Fatalf("stage %s missing trans_label", s.No)
|
||||
}
|
||||
if s.Generate == "ci-jobs" {
|
||||
continue // nodes are generated live, no authored plain
|
||||
}
|
||||
for _, n := range s.Nodes {
|
||||
if n.Plain == "" {
|
||||
t.Fatalf("stage %s node %q missing plain", s.No, n.Title)
|
||||
}
|
||||
}
|
||||
}
|
||||
}
|
||||
|
||||
func TestBuild_ErrorsOnBadAtlasJSON(t *testing.T) {
|
||||
if _, err := atlas.Build([]byte("{not json"), []byte("jobs:\n x:\n a: 1\n")); err == nil {
|
||||
t.Fatal("expected error on bad atlas JSON, got nil")
|
||||
|
||||
+18
-9
@@ -11,9 +11,11 @@ type Host struct {
|
||||
Spec string `json:"k"`
|
||||
}
|
||||
|
||||
// Node is a card within a stage.
|
||||
// Node is a card within a stage. Plain is the jargon-free default text; Desc is
|
||||
// the technical detail shown on demand.
|
||||
type Node struct {
|
||||
Title string `json:"t"`
|
||||
Plain string `json:"plain,omitempty"`
|
||||
Desc string `json:"d,omitempty"`
|
||||
Pill string `json:"pill,omitempty"`
|
||||
Cls string `json:"cls,omitempty"`
|
||||
@@ -22,15 +24,22 @@ type Node struct {
|
||||
Gate bool `json:"gate,omitempty"`
|
||||
}
|
||||
|
||||
// Stage is one column of the pipeline. When Generate is set, its Nodes are
|
||||
// derived from a source at Build time rather than taken from the authored data.
|
||||
// Stage is one column of the pipeline. PlainTitle/Plain are the plain-language
|
||||
// default layer; Title/Path/Nodes[].Desc are the technical layer. TransLabel/
|
||||
// Trans annotate the outgoing transition (the arrow to the next stage): what
|
||||
// moves work forward and what must be true to advance. When Generate is set,
|
||||
// Nodes are derived from a live source at Build time.
|
||||
type Stage struct {
|
||||
No string `json:"no"`
|
||||
Title string `json:"title"`
|
||||
Path string `json:"path,omitempty"`
|
||||
Cls string `json:"cls,omitempty"`
|
||||
Generate string `json:"generate,omitempty"`
|
||||
Nodes []Node `json:"nodes"`
|
||||
No string `json:"no"`
|
||||
Title string `json:"title"`
|
||||
PlainTitle string `json:"plain_title,omitempty"`
|
||||
Plain string `json:"plain,omitempty"`
|
||||
Path string `json:"path,omitempty"`
|
||||
Cls string `json:"cls,omitempty"`
|
||||
Generate string `json:"generate,omitempty"`
|
||||
TransLabel string `json:"trans_label,omitempty"`
|
||||
Trans string `json:"trans,omitempty"`
|
||||
Nodes []Node `json:"nodes"`
|
||||
}
|
||||
|
||||
// Atlas is the full data model the frontend renders.
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -59,6 +59,15 @@
|
||||
display:inline-flex;align-items:center;justify-content:center;
|
||||
font-size:9px;color:#08121f;font-weight:600}
|
||||
|
||||
/* progressive disclosure */
|
||||
.tech-sub{color:var(--dim);font-size:11px;font-family:ui-monospace,SFMono-Regular,monospace;margin:1px 0 5px}
|
||||
.plain-what{color:var(--ink);font-size:12.5px;line-height:1.45;margin-bottom:2px;opacity:.92}
|
||||
.translabel{fill:var(--mono);font-size:10px;font-family:ui-monospace,SFMono-Regular,monospace}
|
||||
.translabel-gate{fill:var(--gold);font-weight:700}
|
||||
.stagehead{min-height:64px}
|
||||
body.plain .stagehead{min-height:188px}
|
||||
.stage .node:first-of-type{margin-top:24px}
|
||||
|
||||
.scroll{overflow-x:auto;padding:24px 22px 20px}
|
||||
.track{position:relative;display:flex;align-items:flex-start;min-width:max-content}
|
||||
svg.spine{position:absolute;left:0;top:0;z-index:0;pointer-events:none;overflow:visible}
|
||||
@@ -123,6 +132,7 @@
|
||||
<h1><b>CAD</b> Atlas · From Signal to Pod</h1>
|
||||
<span class="sub mono">one human gate · everything up- and downstream is agents · <em id="ver">dev</em></span>
|
||||
<div class="controls">
|
||||
<button id="mode" class="on">View · <span id="modeState">Plain</span></button>
|
||||
<button id="replay"><span class="dot"></span> Replay</button>
|
||||
<button id="slowmo">Slow-mo · <span id="slowState">off</span></button>
|
||||
</div>
|
||||
@@ -145,6 +155,7 @@
|
||||
stroke-dasharray="5 5" opacity=".7"></path>
|
||||
<text id="loopLbl" fill="#9b8cff" font-size="11"
|
||||
font-family="ui-monospace,monospace" opacity=".85"></text>
|
||||
<g id="translabels"></g>
|
||||
</svg>
|
||||
<div class="pulse" id="pulse"></div>
|
||||
</div>
|
||||
@@ -163,6 +174,7 @@
|
||||
// empty and are filled by init()'s fetch; on failure the page shows an error
|
||||
// banner rather than stale inline data.
|
||||
let SUBSTRATE=[], NS="", STAGES=[], TIMELINE=[];
|
||||
let MODE = localStorage.getItem('atlas-mode') || 'plain'; // 'plain' | 'technical'
|
||||
|
||||
const track=document.getElementById('track');
|
||||
let stageEls=[];
|
||||
@@ -174,14 +186,22 @@ function renderAtlas(){
|
||||
const mesh=document.createElement('div');mesh.className='host mesh mono';mesh.textContent=NS;sub.appendChild(mesh);
|
||||
stageEls=[];
|
||||
track.querySelectorAll('.stage').forEach(el=>el.remove());
|
||||
const plain = MODE==='plain';
|
||||
STAGES.forEach(s=>{
|
||||
const st=document.createElement('div');st.className='stage '+s.cls;
|
||||
let h=`<div class="no mono">${s.no}</div><h2>${s.title}</h2><div class="path mono">${s.path||''}</div>`;
|
||||
s.nodes.forEach(n=>{
|
||||
const st=document.createElement('div');st.className='stage '+(s.cls||'');
|
||||
const head = plain
|
||||
? `<div class="no mono">${s.no}</div><h2>${s.plain_title||s.title}</h2>`+
|
||||
`<div class="tech-sub">${s.title}</div>`+(s.plain?`<div class="plain-what">${s.plain}</div>`:'')
|
||||
: `<div class="no mono">${s.no}</div><h2>${s.title}</h2><div class="path mono">${s.path||''}</div>`;
|
||||
let h = `<div class="stagehead">${head}</div>`;
|
||||
(s.nodes||[]).forEach(n=>{
|
||||
const pill=n.pill?`<span class="pill" style="background:${n.pill}"></span>`:'';
|
||||
let inner=`<div class="t">${pill}${n.t}</div><div class="d">${n.d}</div>`;
|
||||
if(n.tags&&n.tags.length)inner+=n.tags.map(t=>`<span class="tag mono">${t}</span>`).join('');
|
||||
if(n.risk)inner+=`<div class="risk mono"><span class="lo">LOW · auto</span><span class="md">MED · ntfy gate</span><span class="hi">HIGH · blocked</span></div>`;
|
||||
const body = plain ? (n.plain||n.d||'') : (n.d||'');
|
||||
let inner=`<div class="t">${pill}${n.t}</div>`+(body?`<div class="d">${body}</div>`:'');
|
||||
if(!plain){
|
||||
if(n.tags&&n.tags.length)inner+=n.tags.map(t=>`<span class="tag mono">${t}</span>`).join('');
|
||||
if(n.risk)inner+=`<div class="risk mono"><span class="lo">LOW · auto</span><span class="md">MED · ntfy gate</span><span class="hi">HIGH · blocked</span></div>`;
|
||||
}
|
||||
if(n.gate)inner+=`<div class="gatebtns mono"><div class="g ok">✓ approve</div><div class="g no">✕ reject</div></div>`;
|
||||
h+=`<div class="node ${n.cls||''}">${inner}</div>`;
|
||||
});
|
||||
@@ -207,13 +227,16 @@ function renderTimeline(){
|
||||
const spine=document.getElementById('spine'), spinePath=document.getElementById('spinePath'),
|
||||
loopPath=document.getElementById('loopPath'), loopLbl=document.getElementById('loopLbl'),
|
||||
pulse=document.getElementById('pulse');
|
||||
const RAILY=70;
|
||||
let RAILY=70;
|
||||
let cs=[],loopY=0,spineLen=0,loopLen=0,slow=false,raf=null,t0=null,mobile=false;
|
||||
|
||||
function build(){
|
||||
mobile=window.matchMedia('(max-width:820px)').matches;
|
||||
if(mobile)return;
|
||||
cs=stageEls.map(s=>s.offsetLeft+s.offsetWidth/2);
|
||||
// spine sits in the band between the (uniform) stage headers and the first node
|
||||
const firstTops=stageEls.map(s=>{const n=s.querySelector('.node');return n?s.offsetTop+n.offsetTop:120;});
|
||||
RAILY=Math.max(66, Math.min(...firstTops)-16);
|
||||
const maxBottom=Math.max(...stageEls.map(s=>s.offsetTop+s.offsetHeight));
|
||||
loopY=maxBottom+40;
|
||||
spine.setAttribute('width',track.scrollWidth);
|
||||
@@ -223,7 +246,22 @@ function build(){
|
||||
const lastX=cs[cs.length-1], telosX=cs[1];
|
||||
loopPath.setAttribute('d',`M ${lastX} ${RAILY} L ${lastX} ${loopY} L ${telosX} ${loopY} L ${telosX} ${RAILY}`);
|
||||
loopLbl.setAttribute('x',(telosX+lastX)/2-90);loopLbl.setAttribute('y',loopY-8);
|
||||
loopLbl.textContent='feedback bus · outcome → goal';
|
||||
loopLbl.textContent=(STAGES[8]&&STAGES[8].trans_label?STAGES[8].trans_label+' · ':'')+'feedback bus';
|
||||
// transition labels on the spine — the "what must be true to advance" story.
|
||||
// Always visible (default layer). Gate hops (04→05 human, 06→07 CI) in gold.
|
||||
const tg=document.getElementById('translabels'); tg.innerHTML='';
|
||||
for(let i=0;i<cs.length-1;i++){
|
||||
const s=STAGES[i]; if(!s||!s.trans_label) continue;
|
||||
const gate = (i===4||i===6);
|
||||
const t=document.createElementNS('http://www.w3.org/2000/svg','text');
|
||||
t.setAttribute('x',(cs[i]+cs[i+1])/2);t.setAttribute('y',RAILY-9);
|
||||
t.setAttribute('text-anchor','middle');
|
||||
t.setAttribute('class',gate?'translabel translabel-gate':'translabel');
|
||||
t.textContent=(gate?'▸ ':'')+s.trans_label;
|
||||
const ttl=document.createElementNS('http://www.w3.org/2000/svg','title');
|
||||
ttl.textContent=s.trans||''; t.appendChild(ttl);
|
||||
tg.appendChild(t);
|
||||
}
|
||||
spineLen=spinePath.getTotalLength();loopLen=loopPath.getTotalLength();
|
||||
}
|
||||
function run(ts){
|
||||
@@ -246,6 +284,16 @@ function replay(){cancelAnimationFrame(raf);t0=null;build();if(!mobile)raf=reque
|
||||
document.getElementById('replay').onclick=replay;
|
||||
document.getElementById('slowmo').onclick=e=>{slow=!slow;e.currentTarget.classList.toggle('on',slow);
|
||||
document.getElementById('slowState').textContent=slow?'on':'off';replay();};
|
||||
function applyMode(){
|
||||
document.getElementById('modeState').textContent = MODE==='plain'?'Plain':'Technical';
|
||||
document.getElementById('mode').classList.toggle('on', MODE==='plain');
|
||||
document.body.classList.toggle('plain', MODE==='plain');
|
||||
}
|
||||
document.getElementById('mode').onclick=()=>{
|
||||
MODE = MODE==='plain' ? 'technical' : 'plain';
|
||||
localStorage.setItem('atlas-mode',MODE);
|
||||
applyMode(); renderAtlas(); replay();
|
||||
};
|
||||
window.addEventListener('resize',()=>{clearTimeout(window._r);window._r=setTimeout(replay,150);});
|
||||
async function init(){
|
||||
try{
|
||||
@@ -265,6 +313,7 @@ async function init(){
|
||||
'<div class="path mono">/api/atlas.json failed to load</div></div>');
|
||||
return;
|
||||
}
|
||||
applyMode();
|
||||
renderAtlas();
|
||||
renderTimeline();
|
||||
replay();
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user